Choosing a roof isn’t just about looks—it’s about performance, longevity, and cost. Metal roofing has gained attention for being durable, eco-friendly, and low-maintenance. But it’s not without its downsides, and understanding both sides of the coin is essential before making such a major investment.
In this blog, we’ll break down metal roofing pros and cons so you can clearly understand if it’s the right fit for your home.
Pros of Metal Roofing
Metal roofing comes with several compelling advantages that can make it a smart long-term investment for many homeowners. Below are the most important benefits you should be aware of:
Long Lifespan
Metal roofs are built to last. While traditional asphalt shingles often require replacement within 15 to 20 years, metal roofing systems can easily last 40 to 70 years, depending on the material. Galvanized steel, aluminum, and copper all offer different levels of durability, but even the most basic metal roof will typically outlast most alternatives. This makes it a popular choice for homeowners looking for a one-time investment.
Beyond longevity, metal roofs also maintain their performance and appearance better over time. They don’t crack, warp, or degrade the way other materials do, even after decades of exposure to the elements. This durability translates to fewer repairs and lower lifetime costs, especially in areas prone to harsh weather conditions.
Weather Resistance
One of the biggest strengths of metal roofing is its ability to withstand extreme weather. Properly installed systems are rated for winds up to 140 mph, and they perform well in heavy rain, hailstorms, and snow. Metal sheds snow easily, helping prevent dangerous buildup and roof collapse risks in colder climates. Its hard surface also resists hail better than materials like wood or asphalt.
Additionally, metal is non-combustible, making it a top choice in fire-prone regions. Many metal roofs carry a Class A fire rating—the highest available—meaning they won’t ignite when exposed to fire or flying embers. For homeowners in wildfire zones or hurricane-prone areas, this fire and wind resistance offers added peace of mind.
Energy Efficiency
Metal roofing reflects sunlight rather than absorbing it, reducing the amount of heat that enters your home. This cooling effect can significantly lower air conditioning costs in hot climates, with homeowners seeing average savings of 10–25% on energy bills. Some products are even ENERGY STAR certified or come with special reflective coatings to enhance this benefit.
The energy efficiency of a metal roof can also improve your home’s environmental footprint. By keeping your indoor temperature more stable, your HVAC system doesn’t have to work as hard, which reduces your overall energy use. Over time, this makes a meaningful difference—not just in your wallet, but in your carbon emissions as well.
Low Maintenance
Unlike wood or asphalt shingles that can crack, rot, or invite pests, metal roofs are incredibly low maintenance. There’s no need for frequent patching or treatments. Occasional cleaning to remove debris and a quick check of fasteners and sealants are typically all that’s needed to keep it in top condition.
Because metal is resistant to mildew, moss, and fungus, it also stays cleaner for longer. That means less time and money spent on upkeep or pressure washing. For busy homeowners—or anyone who just wants a hassle-free option—this low-maintenance quality is a major advantage.
Lightweight
Metal roofing panels are surprisingly lightweight, often weighing half as much as asphalt shingles and up to five times less than tile or slate. This lighter load reduces stress on the home’s structure, which can be a major benefit for older homes or those not originally designed to support heavier materials.
A lighter roof also allows for faster and easier installation, which could help reduce labor costs. And if you’re retrofitting over an existing roof, metal’s lightweight can sometimes eliminate the need for a costly tear-off, saving time and money in the installation process.
Environmentally Friendly
Most metal roofs contain 25% to 95% recycled materials and are 100% recyclable at the end of their lifespan. Unlike asphalt shingles that end up in landfills, metal panels can be repurposed or melted down to create new products, reducing waste significantly.
In addition to being recyclable, metal roofs contribute to energy savings, which helps reduce fossil fuel usage. Combined with their long lifespan, this makes them a sustainable and eco-conscious choice for homeowners who want to reduce their environmental impact without compromising durability or aesthetics.
Modern Style Options
Today’s metal roofs come in a wide range of styles, colors, and textures. Whether you want a sleek, modern look or something that mimics traditional shingles or slate, there’s likely a design that complements your home’s architecture. You can even choose from matte finishes, woodgrain textures, or bright colors for a more customized appearance.
This design versatility makes metal roofing a great fit for various home styles—rural cottages, city row houses, and everything in between. It’s not just functional anymore; it can be a statement piece that boosts curb appeal and resale value.
Resistant to Insects and Rodents
Metal roofing is impervious to pests such as termites, ants, and rodents, which can cause significant damage to traditional roofing materials like wood. Insects and rodents often infest materials like wood shakes, leading to rot, holes, and structural weakness. Since metal is inorganic and does not provide a food source, it is far less likely to be infested by pests.
This resistance to pests not only helps preserve the integrity of the roof but also reduces the need for pest control treatments. Homeowners can avoid costly interventions, providing further cost savings and peace of mind in terms of roof durability.
Improved Property Value
Metal roofing can significantly increase your property’s resale value. Because of its durability, aesthetic appeal, and energy efficiency, potential buyers are often willing to pay more for homes that feature a metal roof. Many buyers consider a metal roof an upgrade that will save them money in the long term due to its long lifespan and reduced maintenance needs.
In addition, the energy-efficient properties of metal roofing are an attractive selling point. With rising energy costs, prospective buyers may appreciate the idea of a roofing system that reduces heating and cooling bills. This added value can make your home more marketable and appealing in a competitive real estate market.
Snow and Ice Shed Efficiency
Metal roofing performs exceptionally well in areas with heavy snowfall and ice. Unlike traditional roofing materials, which can accumulate snow and create ice dams, metal roofs are designed to shed snow quickly. This reduces the risk of water pooling on the roof, preventing ice dams that can lead to leaks and other structural problems.
The smooth, slippery surface of metal roofing allows snow and ice to slide off naturally, which can protect your home’s foundation and prevent costly water damage. This feature is particularly useful for homeowners in cold climates, ensuring that your roof performs well throughout winter without the need for constant snow removal.
Read More: The Ultimate Guide to Roof Repair in 2025
Cons of Metal Roofing
Despite its benefits, metal roofing isn’t for everyone. It’s important to understand the potential drawbacks so you can weigh the pros and cons based on your budget, climate, and long-term plans.
High Initial Cost
One of the most significant drawbacks of metal roofing is its high initial cost. While metal roofing can save money in the long run due to its durability and low maintenance needs, the upfront cost of materials and installation can be considerably more expensive than traditional roofing options like asphalt shingles. Metal roofs can cost up to two to three times more than asphalt shingles, and the installation requires skilled labor, which can further add to the expense.
For homeowners on a tight budget, this can be a significant disadvantage. While the investment might pay off over time through reduced maintenance and longer lifespan, the initial cost can be a barrier for many.
Noise Concerns
While metal roofs are known for their durability, they can create unwanted noise, especially during heavy rain, hailstorms, or when snow slides off the roof. Unlike traditional roofing materials like shingles or tiles, metal roofs don’t have the sound-dampening qualities that other materials might have.
This noise can be particularly disturbing in areas with extreme weather conditions, leading homeowners to consider additional soundproofing options, which can increase the overall cost of the installation. Homeowners who live in regions with frequent storms or heavy rainfall may find this to be a considerable downside.
Denting and Dings
Though metal roofs are highly durable, they can be prone to dents from falling branches, hail, or debris. If a tree branch falls on the roof, it may leave a visible dent or scratch that can mar the roof’s appearance. This is particularly true for softer metals, such as aluminum, which are more susceptible to damage.
Additionally, while some metal roofing systems are resistant to damage from hail, severe weather conditions can still result in cosmetic damage. This is a drawback for homeowners who want a flawless roof with no visible imperfections. The cost of repairs for dents or dings can add up over time, especially if damage occurs regularly.
Expansion and Contraction Issues
Metal roofs expand and contract with changes in temperature, which can cause stress on the material. During hot summer days, metal roofs can expand, and during colder temperatures, they contract. This movement can lead to potential issues such as fasteners loosening, panels shifting, and gaps forming, which may allow water infiltration.
Proper installation techniques are essential to avoid these issues, but even with expert installation, some movement is inevitable. Homeowners should factor in these natural fluctuations when considering metal roofing.
Installation Complexity
Metal roofing requires specialized installation, which is more complicated than installing traditional roofing materials. It’s essential to hire experienced contractors who are familiar with the specific requirements of metal roof installation. Improper installation can lead to issues such as leaks, poor insulation, or the roof’s failure to properly expand and contract with temperature changes.
The complexity of installation often results in a higher labor cost. Homeowners must factor this into the overall expense of choosing metal roofing.
Read More: Westchester Roofing Trends and Innovations for 2025
Limited Color Selection
While metal roofing is available in several colors, the color options may be more limited compared to other roofing materials such as asphalt shingles. Asphalt shingles, for example, are available in a broad range of colors and textures, while metal roofing tends to have a more standardized color palette.
Additionally, certain colors on metal roofing can fade over time due to the effects of sunlight, harsh weather, or extreme temperature fluctuations. This could result in an uneven appearance that may require periodic touch-ups or repainting to maintain the roof’s aesthetic value.
Vulnerability to Rust
Metal roofs are susceptible to rust and corrosion, particularly if the coating on the metal is compromised. Over time, exposure to rain, snow, and humidity can cause metal roofing materials to corrode, leading to holes or leaks.
While most modern metal roofs are treated with protective coatings to resist rust and corrosion, older roofs or poorly maintained metal roofs may be more vulnerable. Homeowners must ensure that their metal roof is regularly inspected and maintained to prevent rust from causing significant damage.
Slippery Surface
The slipperiness of metal roofing can be a concern, especially when it is covered with snow or ice. This can make walking on the roof dangerous for homeowners or contractors performing maintenance tasks. Unlike shingle roofs, which have more friction and grip, metal roofs can become very slippery, leading to potential accidents.
For areas that experience heavy snowfall or ice buildup, homeowners may need to install snow guards or take extra precautions to ensure safety when accessing the roof.
Higher Insurance Premiums
In certain situations, metal roofing can lead to higher insurance premiums. While metal roofs are known for being fire-resistant, they are more prone to damage from hail or heavy winds. This potential for costly repairs or replacements in the event of severe weather may cause some insurance providers to raise premiums for homeowners with metal roofs.
Additionally, because metal roofs are more expensive to repair or replace, some insurance companies may charge more to cover the risk of roof damage.
Potential for Fading and Deterioration
While metal roofing is highly durable, it can still suffer from fading and deterioration over time, particularly if it is exposed to harsh UV rays or extreme weather conditions. The surface coating on metal roofs is designed to protect against wear and tear, but over time, UV exposure, wind, rain, and other environmental factors can degrade the finish.
When the coating begins to wear down, the roof may lose its color and aesthetic appeal, requiring repainting or recoating to restore its appearance. Regular maintenance is essential to avoid premature fading and to ensure the roof retains its visual appeal.
Need Help With Metal Roofing Pros and Cons?
If you’re still weighing your options, let a trusted professional guide you. Delta Roofing Westchester has years of experience helping homeowners choose the right roofing solution for their needs. From honest assessments to high-quality installations, our team makes sure you feel confident every step of the way. Whether metal roofing is right for you or not, we’ll help you make the best decision for your home.
Make the right choice for your roof—contact us today to schedule your consultation!
